Saab GRIPEN E: Interoperability and Low Operational Cost Make This Smart Fighter from Saab an Attractive Option for Canada

CDR Archives: Vol. 27, Issue 2 Cover Story

Saab Gripen E

With renewed interest in the RCAF operating a mixed fleet of F-35s and Gripens, CDR is revisiting one of our most popular features– Vol. 27, Issue 2 Cover Story on Saab’s Gripen fighter below.

BY JOETEY ATTARIWWALA

Saab carries on business throughout the world as a defence and security company that aims to keep its customers and their communities secure from threats wherever and however they arise. And, it does all that via products like fighter aircraft, airborne early warning systems, radars, electronic warfare, submarines, ground combat, and missile systems.

The company has been operating in Canada for nearly 30 years and has products in service across the Army, Navy and Air Force, along with the commercial aviation sector. One important example is the Combat Management System and surveillance and fire control systems onboard the Halifax Class frigates of the Royal Canadian Navy. These systems are at the heart of these ships as they carry out their NORAD maritime warning missions. 

Now, in response to Canada’s FFCP (Future Fighter Capability Project) RFP, Saab Canada has proposed the cutting edge Gripen E fighter jet as their solution to replace the venerable CF-18 Hornet. 

Gripen has been developed in a very agile manner, which was made possible by the close cooperation between the Swedish Air Force and industry. Among the key features of the Gripen E that make it particularly well suited for FFCP, are ability to assemble the aircraft in Canada, technology transfer to Canada, a design built to withstand and thrive in Canada’s harsh climate, NATO interoperability, low maintenance and sustainment costs, as well as a small operational footprint, to name but a few.

“We truly appreciate how important military alliances such as NORAD and NATO are in the context of Canada’s Strong, Secure, Engaged defence policy, and we are proud of our continued support to the Canadian Armed Forces,” said Micael Johansson, CEO and President of Saab.  “We recognize that selecting Canada’s future fighter is a vital decision that needs to support not just the NORAD and NATO commitments, but also has to support national sovereignty and autonomy. With our Gripen E, the Future Fighter Capability Project will provide Canada with an opportunity to create generational economic benefits with a focus on the aerospace sector.”

Micael Johansson

To pursue FFCP, Saab has joined forces with leading Canadian aerospace companies IMP Aerospace & Defence, CAE, Peraton Canada and GE Aviation to form the ‘Gripen for Canada Team’.  Saab’s bid to the Government of Canada will include a comprehensive proposal to deliver industrial and technological benefits and the attendant high-quality jobs which will add significant economic value across Canadian industry, coast to coast.

“Our bid offers an unrivaled industrial and technological benefits package that puts Canadian companies in a position to generate new long-term sustainable employment opportunities in highly skilled careers, and to do so in established locations as well as other areas where the investment will be most beneficial to Canada,” said Johansson. 

He added, “If Gripen is selected as Canada’s future fighter, Saab is committed to build, support, sustain, enhance and upgrade Canada’s Gripen in Canada by Canadians. In doing so, Saab will add several thousand new sustained jobs for decades.”

Adding to those comments was, Jonas Hjelm, Senior Vice President and head of Business Area Aeronautics who proclaimed, “We have assembled a dynamic roster of innovative leaders within Canada’s aerospace industry, across multiple regions to offer the best solution for Canada’s future fighter. Saab is committed to securing long-term relationships in Canada that will create a significant number of highly-skilled, sustainable jobs for Canadians within domestic and international supply chains.”

READ: Saab to Consider Canada for its Gripen Jet Assembly

FLYING GRIPEN E

We recognize that most RCAF fighter pilots have never flown a Gripen so, to address this, CDR reached out to Johan Linder, a fighter pilot who flew the Gripen A/B/C/D models and the F/A-18C/D Hornet.  His comparison of both aircraft lays the foundation for a discussion on the Gripen E, which is much more advanced than the Gripen he flew. Here are his words:

After flying the Gripen A/B/C/D for 15 years and the F/A-18C/D for 3 years, I will start by saying that they are both very impressive, yet completely different aircraft in terms of generation, air frame, system availability and integration as well as design philosophy.

The F/A-18 is a very powerful and agile aircraft when looking at it from a snapshot perspective.  One of the usable features with the Hornet is the pilot’s ability to pull a great deal of AoA in order to get a shot off.  This is absolutely an upside when it comes to a desired end-game maneuverability if the gun is the only remaining weapon. However, changes in weaponry with today’s high-off boresight missiles and a desire to complete engagements on a greater and safer distance, does make this feature less important in modern air-combat.

On the backside off the high AoA possibility, the Hornet has a real problem regaining speed after such energy excursions. The pilot is additionally left with an aircraft that is trimmed to a quite high AoA after yanking back at the stick.  From here a pilot must actively push himself out of the AoA to regain speed with a likely altitude loss as a result. Flying at lower levels, the problem with AoA induced drag is not quite as big, due to better engine thrust allowing the aircraft to regain speed a bit better.

Saab GRIPEN E fighter jet in the grey sky

The danger when ending up in a low speed, high AoA situation is inarguably the risk of an engine failure. Even though the fuselage has been optimized to cover disturbed and reduced airflow into the engines, the inlet design might not be enough to handle such induced engine stress.  Hornet drivers have great respect for high AoA maneuvering at low level due to this.

The Gripen is built on a different AoA philosophy. The aircraft is never skidding through the air while bleeding airspeed, it rather carves through the air while maintaining enough speed to complete a follow-on maneuver.  Maintaining energy throughout maneuvers up to 9G is one of the very good features of Gripen’s envelope.  The aircraft flies very precise at any speed and trims automatically so that the pilot never needs to worry about it.  A Hornet pilot used to rudder rolling at low speeds, can rest his feet in a Gripen.  Pilots flying the Gripen are able to maneuver aggressively down to the hard deck, without adding safety margins. This brings a new dimension to the term “care-free maneuvering.”

The Gripen is capable of supersonic flight on just military power and pilots who converted to Gripen from the Swedish Viggen fighter, often called Gripen “slippery” as the aircraft’s low drag both made it easy to slip into the transonic region, as well as the ease to regain speed. That being said, most pilots often want to access more power in many situations, regardless of platform.

In terms of system management, a Gripen pilot gets the feeling of having everything where it “should” be. The support functions as well as tactical system functions are from a pilot’s perspective perceived as truly smart. Such an HMI [Human-Machine Interface] increases a pilot’s capacity in operation because it enables very effective attention shifting in addition to the many automated options that are available to the pilot. Lifesaving functions such as automatic fly-up [AFU] and automatic recovery provide back-up to the pilot. Troubleshooting in a Gripen is a piece of cake compared to the Hornet. A paper copy of the Emergency Pocket Checklist is brought along for each flight, but instead of the 100 or so pages used for Hornet operations, a Gripen Pilot has around 10 pages.

The Gripen is a comparably light aircraft and has an impressive braking system which utilizes lift-dump by the canards at landing, creating an effective down-force assisting in the braking. Due to Sweden’s dispersal concept, the Gripen is designed for short landings, quick turnarounds and short take-offs. The road strips used for highway-landings are 2,600 ft long. This requires a pilot to land with a slightly higher AoA than usual, tailwind should certainly be avoided, and the brakes can be applied already prior to touchdown.

In my experience from Hornet operations, a turnaround often took 70 minutes, whereas 30 minutes is sufficient for the Gripen. A quick turnaround including mounting weapons and hot refueling in the Gripen takes less than 10 minutes to complete.

Comparing the Gripen HMI to the Hornet, there are clear generation gaps in most features. In the Hornet, I was always diverting much more attention to managing both the aircraft and its systems. I had to work much more sequentially than simultaneously. As a pilot I have a much greater ability to fulfill my task in a Gripen because I have free brain capacity to either do it better or add on additional tasks.

The HOTAS in the Hornet was a bit of a shock when I realized that it often meant moving a cursor around on the display before clicking the text that corresponded to the preferred option. As a comparison I had to use a combination of 6 HOTAS actions in order to reset the radar in the Hornet to the desired state. The same reset takes one HOTAS action in the Gripen. Gripen’s much smaller and harder stick and “pistol-like” power/radar grip, provide completely different HOTAS possibilities. The functionality makes it effortless and quick.

When further comparing the capabilities of the F/A-18C/D and Gripen, tactical systems are very well integrated in the Gripen. Starting up the jet, the default setting on the systems is ON, whereas the Hornet to a large extent require the systems to manually be switched ON. The number of options of how to set up your systems in a Gripen, corresponds to the number of Gripen pilots. This user-friendly environment has often led Gripen squadrons to assume roles such as self-escorting strikers or organic fighter escort when participating in Composite Air Operations.

To ensure success in every role the Gripen is for example equipped with Link 16, secure voice, Rover link, Digital-CAS and Havequick radio amongst other enabling functions. Should the MIDS transmission for any reason be unavailable, the aircraft has its own secure tactical datalink called TIDLS ready to switch on. On the Hornet, a MIDS failure for whatever reason, would result going directly into a contingency plan.

SMART DESIGN

Like some other famous Swedish companies, Saab’s development ethos is based on smart design. This design philosophy is built upon decades of aerospace engineering excellence. The Gripen E variant builds on the already impressive Gripen C, and its smart design is specifically meant to provide enhanced capabilities against new and emerging threats emanating from near peer adversaries like Russia and China – these include but are not limited to the Su-57 and J-20 aircraft, and the S-400 missile system.

The Gripen E has now been delivered for joint verification programs involving Swedish and Brazilian customers, and Saab is actively engaged with fighter procurement competitions in Europe, Asia, South America as well as Canada. 

The Gripen E is the largest variant of the Gripen family – the bigger platform allows for more internal fuel capacity which provides greater range and endurance, and an expanded weapons capacity by way of additional hard points (10 in all).  A key attribute of the Gripen E’s mission system design is its open avionics architecture which partitions the flight critical avionics from the tactical systems avionics. 

This design is revolutionary and is one of the greatest advances compared to other fighters — this approach allows operators to upgrade non-flight critical systems without affecting critical flight functions. This enables the Gripen E to accept rapid integration of new capabilities, and allows for the validation of new components without the need for lengthy re-certification testing, which in turn reduces development time and cost. 

Patrick Palmer is Vice President and Director of Marketing and Sales at Saab Canada and for this report he told CDR, “To describe it simply, the Gripen E’s tactical systems can be upgraded just like cell phone applications, without the need to make structural changes to the fighter, or to recertify for airworthiness. It would allow Canada to have a state-of-the-art fleet for decades to come, with continued upgrades staying in front of technology throughout the fleet’s full life cycle.”

COMBAT CAPABILITY

The Gripen E’s combat capability is on par with and in some cases exceeds every modern fighter out there today. Although it’s not a low observable platform, the Gripen has a small radar cross section and it uses emission control as one method to remain undetected. The platform integrates all of its sensor’s data — Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radar, infrared search and track (IRST), Electronic Warfare (EW), missile approach warning (MAW) and others — through sensor fusion and presents information to the pilot via an optimized Human-Machine Interface which includes a Wide Area Display with touchscreen functionality, a large Heads-Up Display, Hands-On Throttle and Stick (HOTAS) functionality, and a helmet mounted cueing system.

The Gripen E’s Skyward-G IRST is a long-range electro-optical sensor which provides an exceptional tactical advantage as the passive system detects the heat signatures of other airborne systems but cannot be detected in return. With the IRST, a Gripen can detect and track enemy targets, including aircraft, naval vessels and ground vehicles. The system also has a significant ‘counter-stealth’ capability and, when used alone or in conjunction with Gripen’s other sensors, it can produce high-fidelity tracking information against complex targets over long ranges, beyond visual range.

Saab is an expert in radar and EW technology, so it is no surprise the Gripen E employs a robust EW suite, which many say is unrivaled. The embedded EW system ensures that it can enter highly contested airspace with advanced surface and air threats. To do this the Gripen’s EW system has a full 360-degree spherical coverage with passive countermeasures as well as active jamming capability. The EW system is principally software defined and customizable, which means it can be continuously updated to ensure the Gripen remains operationally relevant as new threats emerge.

“The pilot doesn’t really have to think about how to maneuver the aircraft while being intercepted by a missile or to gain situational awareness because we have true 360-degree spherical coverage in the Gripen E,” explained Jonas Groenberg, Head of Marketing and Sales Fighter Aircraft EW at Saab.  “You can use that information to cue up your ECM [External Counter Measures] for being reactive, pre-emptive, or more or less offensive to build a tactical advantage for your aircraft.”

BETTER SITUATIONAL AWARENESS

Robin Nordlander, a Gripen E Test Pilot at Saab, told CDR, “What’s important for me as a fighter pilot is the Gripen E’s EW suite has much higher resolution, much better coverage, much higher sensitivity, and more powerful jamming capacity, which means that I will have a better view of every active sensor around me at much higher distance. That combined with sensor fusion gives me much better situational awareness and decision support for my actions.”

Not only does the Gripen E have a robust EW suite, but it can also suppress enemy air defences by way of electronic attack with the Electronic Attack Jammer Pod (EAJP) and the lightweight Air-Launched Decoy Missile (LADM).

The Gripen was the first test bed aircraft for the Meteor beyond visual range air-to-air missile, a weapon that has changed the game of air-to-air combat. Saab successfully completed the first air carriage flight with Meteor on Gripen E in 2018.  Operating together with the AESA radar’s 200-degree coverage, the Meteor missile gives the Gripen pilot the ability to strike with high precision from beyond the horizon and maintain missile data link while turning away. The Gripen E can carry up to seven Meteor missiles and it can also integrate an array of advanced weapons from various providers including American, European and Israeli weapons. These weapons include the AIM-120 AMRAAM and AIM-9 missiles, and Guided Bomb Unit (GBU) munitions which Canada currently employs.

In addition to its air-to-air and air-to-ground capability, the Gripen E is also adept at air-to-surface warfare by way of the RBS15 Gungnir anti-ship missile. This capability cannot be understated, particularly when near peer adversaries like China continue to build one of the largest navies on the planet. With a flight range of more than 300 km, depending on solution, the Gungnir is designed to dominate the littoral environment and operate effectively over blue water and on land.

IMP TO ASSEMBLE GRIPEN E FIGHTER IN CANADA

IMP Aerospace & Defence will contribute with in-country production and in-service support for the life of the Canadian Gripen fleet. CAE will provide training and mission systems solutions, while Peraton Canada will provide avionics and test equipment component maintenance, repair and overhaul, and material management. GE Aviation would provide and sustain the fighter’s F414 engines in Canada.

“The Gripen for Canada Team presents a genuine made-in-Canada solution and we look forward to demonstrating how the Gripen E is the best value for Canada’s aerospace industry and taxpayers in terms of life-cycle costs and sustainment throughout the FFCP competition,” said Saab’s Palmer. “The Gripen E fighter meets all of Canada’s specific defence requirements and offers exceptional performance, advanced technical capabilities, future-proof upgradeability and NATO interoperability.”

Clark Bain is Senior Vice President Strategic Development at IMP Aerospace & Defence and he told CDR, “Final assembly, integration and test of the Gripen E will happen at our facilities in Halifax. There will be some specialized test infrastructure that we’ll need to build, like a hush house for engine run-ups. One of the really clever things about the Gripen is the elegant way it is designed for manufacture and sustainment.  We will have to set up some tooling for the production line here, but it’s not a massive challenge partially because of the way the aircraft is designed.”

He added, “In terms of workforce, some recruitment will have to take place, and over the course of the program hundreds of jobs trades will be sustained here. What will be completely new for us is running an entire production line from a 3D model.  I suspect that becomes a very efficient way to run the production line and it will flow through to sustainment as well.  What we’ve seen in Sweden is a far more efficient way of working so I strongly suspect that we will probably re-orient ourselves to that method. The implication of that is’ not only will DND see efficiency with the Gripen, but it will also see efficiencies in all the other programs we work on.”

With the selection of Gripen as Canada’s future fighter, Saab will establish two new aerospace centers in the greater Montreal region. These two centers together with Saab’s commitment to build in Canada are means the creation of several thousand new sustained jobs for decades.  These high skilled jobs will help reinvigorate Canada’s aerospace sector while at the same time spurring development in new areas of research. 

If selected by Canada, Saab plans to build a Gripen Center which will be managed by Canadians and will host the Canadian Fighter Mission System for the Gripen. “The hosting of the Fighter Mission System includes the ability to conduct domestic research and development for the system, along with the opportunity to perform technological upgrades in order to respond to the ever-evolving threats. These capabilities will provide Canada with a Fighter Mission System that is not only built in Canada, but can meet Canada’s domestic, NORAD and NATO obligations,” Saab’s Johansson explained. 

He added, “In addition, the Gripen Center will also play a key role in the co-ordination of the sustainment of the Gripen and its associated systems including upgrades, fleet management, repairs and modifications. This center will be the national Gripen crown jewel in Canada. The Gripen for Canada Team members will provide the vast majority of the staff alongside Canadians employed by Saab.  Overall, this will provide Canada with a fighter managed and controlled by Canadians that will be secured under Saab’s proven technology and knowledge transfer program that is unmatched by anyone.”

The promise of IP and technology transfer for Gripen E to Canada is one backed by a solid track record. Saab has been delivering Gripen E in Brazil, with heavy involvement of Brazilian industry, and will soon begin to manufacture Gripen E fighters in-country there.

NORAD & NATO INTEROPERABILITY

A critical aspect for any discussion on fighter procurement is operational support cost, and no one does this better than the Swedish Armed Forces who are world renowned for their ability to operate weapon systems in austere conditions with a very small support footprint. This capability is baked into the Gripen E as the platform can be supported for full combat employment with as few as four support personnel. This attribute becomes essential when operating across large areas which is typical in Sweden and in Canada.

General Jeffrey Harrigian, Commander, U.S. Air Forces in Europe-Africa and Commander Allied Air Command, talked about the interoperability issue, “Our Swedish and Finnish partners are critically important to us up in the Arctic, and I would highlight to you that we have an exercise that we execute in co-ordination with the Norwegians called Arctic Challenge. It’s a great opportunity for us to work up in the Arctic region to not only refine the interoperabilities, but importantly the tactics, techniques and procedures that facilitate our ability to operate together as a team.  Another key capability that we get to explore with the Swedish and Finn partners, who quite frankly are experts at this, is agile combat employment. As you’re probably well aware, the Finns and the Swedes are extraordinary in their ability to distribute assets, protect themselves in a manner that is quite informative to us, and at the same time generate combat power.”

In fact, this interoperability was demonstrated in May 2020 and March 2021 when U.S. Air Force B-1B Lancers integrated with Swedish Gripens as part of a long-range, long-duration Bomber Task Force mission. This certainly indicates that the Gripen is interoperable with U.S. forces and that’s a key requirement in the context of NORAD.

The Gripen is also fully interoperable with NATO as exemplified by both the Hungarian and the Czech Republic Armed Forces, NATO partners who operate the Gripen as their respective frontline fighter jets.

With this feature we have attempted to accurately detail the Gripen E’s superb capabilities as a smart fighter but, all things considered, we think you will agree it would be an excellent addition to the RCAF fleet and at the same time, provide a much-needed boost to Canada’s aerospace industry.

Joetey Attariwala is CDR’s Senior Staff Writer & Aviation Editor